Discussion : Engagement and Disengagement

Assignment:

Respond to two of your colleagues’ that contain a perspective other than yours. Your response will typically be 2–3 paragraphs in length, as a general expectation.

· View Two (2) of Colleagues’ discussions “See below”

· Share an insight about what you learned from having read your colleagues’ postings and discuss how and why your colleague’s posting resonated with you professionally and personally. (Note: This may be a great opportunity to help you think about passions you share with your colleagues

· Offer an example from your experience or observation that validates what your colleague discussed.

· Offer specific suggestions that will help your colleague build upon his or her perceptions as a leader.

· Offer further assessment from having read your colleague’s post that could impact a leader’s effectiveness.

· Share how something your colleague discussed changed the way you consider your own qualities.

· No plagiarism

1st Colleague – J. Moore

Engagement and Disengagement

My experience with an engaged employee took place during a training session with a partner organization. The facilitator was full of energy, intensity, and lightheartedness. Her balance in these areas kept me on the edge of my seat with a desire to want to work even closer with this organization because of her passion for their mission that she so vividly explained. You felt that this individual would bleed her company’s values and vision if she were cut. There was a sense that she landed in her dream job as something she aspired to do all her life. It is said that “Enthusiasm Moves the World” and this highly engaged employee moved my world for the better.

My experience with a disengaged employee happened during a visit I made to sell my products. This person wanted no connection to his company because he felt his job was meaningless. Just a paycheck to keep the lights on. There was no initiative to promote team mission achievement with a sense that each day was irrelevant. I ran out of that place!

The difference was night and day. An attitude of gratitude on one hand and a mentality of futility on the other.

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

2nd Colleague – Britnney P

My experience was when I took the DEIA (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Accessibility) facilitator course. The course Instructor was full of energy and seemed passionate about the subject. He was engaging and made me feel engaged. I felt like he connected with every single student there and that was amazing to me. We all were sharing great ideas and helping each other understand. It felt more like a bonding experience of valuable like minded individuals than just a course.

At an operations meeting at work, my leadership only asked the people she considered to be good at operations, questions on help or a way forward. The rest of our opinions were not valued and she completely ignored us. It made me feel small and I definitely didn’t want to be there any longer or want to participate. It made me feel almost betrayed by her as my leadership and resentful of the others. So in this scenario, I was the disengaged worker and you could tell by my silence and body language. When people had to interact with me my dialogue was short and provided nothing else.

The experiences I think differ in the environment and the feeling of value added. We are more engaged when we feel valuable and like what we have to say matters. It made me value other things outside of work which is no longer my happy place.

Top of Form

,

Define Engagement

Satisfaction and commitment are not what drive sustained organizational performance; rather, it is employee engagement that really makes the difference. “Engagement” is not just another popular buzzword; it is critical for business professionals to develop a nuanced understanding of what engagement is and how it can be fostered through effective management strategies.

In this module, you will define “engagement” and determine how it manifests in observable behavior. You will identify how engagement predicts performance. You will explore what engagement looks and feels like through conducting a self-assessment. You will hear from Professor Nishii on the research behind the business case for improving engagement. You will distinguish between engagement and employee attitudes such as organizational satisfaction, commitment, and pride. You will have an opportunity to participate in a discussion on observed behaviors related to engagement versus disengagement, and you will review data related to engagement.

Note to learners: A brief interview (5 to 10 minutes) with an effective leader will be a required component of this course; you may want to schedule that interview now.

Okay, let’s begin by talking about what engagement looks like. People who are engaged are totally absorbed in their work, And they experience what some people call flow, and they’re very, very mindful about the work that they do. They invest their head, their heart, and their hands, their physical energy into their work. And the idea is that people who are engaged personally value and identify with the work that they’re doing. And because their work conditions help them to feel safe about pouring themselves into their work and help motivate them to do that, they say things like, I’m so passionate about my work that it doesn’t feel like work. Engagement is something that you can see in people. It’s visible to the outside. It’s visible in the form of high levels of effort, and involvement, and mindfulness. High levels of intrinsic motivation. You know when someone is really engaged and they’re really into their work, you can see it very, very clearly. They tend to be very difficult to distract. They tend to take initiative to make sure that things go well because they really care that things go well. And they clearly feel energized by their work. They derive energy from the work that they do. And they don’t easily get discouraged by obstacles. And, in fact, obstacles seem to make them work harder towards achieving their goals.

What the Research Says About Engagement

Key Points

Engagement refers to purpose, focused energy, and flow.

Engaged people pore over their work.

Engagement is clearly distinguished from workaholism.

What does engagement really mean? Let’s look at what some of the research has to say. It refers to “an individual’s sense of purpose and focused energy, evident to others in the display of personal initiative, adaptability, effort, and persistence directed toward organizational goals” (Macey, Schneider, Barbera & Young, 2009).

Engagement refers to “the employment and expression of a person’s  preferred self… people who are engaged keep their selves within a role, without sacrificing one for the other” (Kahn, 1990, p.700). The premise is that engaged people pour their personal cognitive, physical, and emotional energies into their work, as manifested in effort, involvement, flow, mindfulness, and intrinsic motivation. When people are engaged, they bring their real identity, thoughts, and feelings to bear on their work, such that their true self and their work role merge. Such people drive their true self into their roles, and their true self gets expressed within their role. In other words, a job is not just a job but is an authentic extension of one’s self.

· The investment of physical energy translates into an increased display of organizationally valued behaviors.

· The investment of cognitive energy promotes behavior that is more focused and mindful.

· The investment of emotional energy promotes increased connections with coworkers and greater authenticity at work.

When people are fully engaged in their work, you can see it clearly in their behavior. They tend to be very focused and difficult to distract (because they want to be doing what they’re doing), they take lots of initiative to make sure things go well because they genuinely care, they dedicate a lot of energy to their work without it feeling like a burden, and they persist even in the face of obstacles; again because their work is an important part of their identity and self-expression.

It is important to distinguish engagement from workaholism, or working excessively and compulsively. Research suggests that the more engaged employees are, the harder they work, the better they feel, and the better they perform. Although workaholism is also related to working hard and performing well, it is additionally associated with poor well-being (Schaufeli, Taris & Bakker, 2006).

Examine Disengagement

It’s important to know what disengagement looks like. People who are disengaged are not vigilant about quality. They tend to be satisfied with “good enough.” They are also much less likely to innovate. When people withdraw, they remove personal energies. You can see this when people become robotic in their work, are apathetic or detached, and are burned out or effortless. When people disengage and become defensive, they hide their true identity, thoughts, and feelings; people go through the motions of work but do not give of themselves in their work. They are driven more by what they have to do than by what they want to do, as Professor Nishii explains.

Okay, now let’s examine disengagement. Disengagement is when people withdraw from their work physically, cognitively, and emotionally. And like engagement, disengagement is also easy to spot. People tend to become robotic, they tend to become apathetic or detached from their work, and they seem burnt out and somewhat effortless as they go about their work. And disengaged individuals tend to hide their true identity, thoughts, and feelings. Having disengaged employees is problematic for organizations because disengaged employees tend to go through the motions of work because they have to, not because they want to. And as a result, they’re not vigilant about the quality of their work, and they’re satisfied with good enough. And they also often fail to develop close and meaningful relationships with their co-workers. And they’re highly unlikely to innovate in their jobs. 

I think we’ve probably all had experiences with customer service representatives, right? Some who are very engaged and extremely helpful, and go out of their way, clearly go out of their way, to help us to feel satisfied, right? To fix a problem. And then we’ve also, I think, all had experiences with the customer service agent who is disengaged and who seems annoyed that we’re asking for help, even though it’s their job. And we can be pretty sure that they’re not really trying all that hard to try to help us fix our problem. And so, like engagement, disengagement is visible to the people around.

The Checklist of Behaviors Indicating Disengagement

Download the Tool

Use this helpful  Checklist of Behaviors Indicating DisengagementLinks to an external site.  to identify whether disengagement behaviors are present

Use this checklist to identify signs of disengagement within a work group. You may choose to use this as a self-reflection activity (assessing yourself and your own behavior) or as a tool to assess the behaviors of an individual direct report or members of a particular work group. The goal of this exercise is not to criticize or find fault with people’s behavior but to deepen your understanding of the behaviors that indicate disengagement. It will also help you develop hypotheses about why people may have become disengaged, as well as what influential strategies you might recommend for line managers to improve people’s level of engagement.

image1.png

Graduatewriterhelp.com Plagiarism Free Papers

Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we\’ll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.

Why Hire Graduatewriterhelp.com writers to do your paper?

Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.

We write plagiarism Free Content

Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.

Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.